Mamdani Wants Rikers Island Closed by 2032. What Happens to the 6,600 People Inside?
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani has unveiled a plan to shut down Rikers Island, but anyone expecting the jail's gates to close anytime soon will be disappointed.
The proposal, announced Friday, November 20, would move the last detainees off the island by December 31, 2032. That's more than five years beyond the August 2027 closure deadline New York City lawmakers approved in 2019.
And with roughly 6,600 people currently held at Rikers, the obvious question is where they'll all go.
The answer is a combination of new jails, hospital-based detention units and a major effort to reduce the number of people held in custody.
Mamdani wants four smaller jails built across Brooklyn, the Bronx, Queens and Manhattan. Together, they're expected to provide 4,160 beds, with another 340 beds in hospital facilities for people requiring more intensive medical or psychiatric care.
Brooklyn's jail is scheduled to open in 2029, followed by facilities in the Bronx and Queens in 2031. Manhattan's would be the last, opening in 2032.
But that still leaves a problem. New York City's current jail population is thousands higher than the replacement system is designed to accommodate.
The administration wants to bring that population down to no more than 4,100 by 2032.
Rather than simply releasing everyone from Rikers, the plan calls for expanding supervised release and alternatives to detention, speeding up criminal cases, improving access to bail payments and providing more treatment and support services.
Most people held at Rikers are awaiting trial rather than serving sentences following convictions. The administration argues that reducing unnecessary pretrial detention and lengthy court delays would help bring down the population.
That doesn't mean everyone charged with a crime will be released. Judges will continue making detention and release decisions under New York law, while people who must remain in custody would eventually be housed in the replacement facilities.
The mayor's proposal includes $146 million in new funding next fiscal year for mental health care, substance-use treatment, education, job training and other services, including support for crime victims.
Rikers has faced years of criticism over violence, deaths in custody, inadequate medical care and dangerous conditions for detainees and correctional staff. A federal court has also intervened in the management of the city's troubled jail system.
But closing the island isn't without controversy.
People are concerned and question whether the city can safely reduce its jail population by thousands while maintaining public safety. Others warn that moving detainees into newer buildings won't fix the problems unless the Department of Correction changes how its facilities operate.
There's also the question of what happens to Rikers Island itself.
The city has been exploring plans to repurpose the property for renewable energy, wastewater treatment and other environmental infrastructure. One aging jail building was permanently closed in June, with portions of the island transferred away from the Department of Correction.
Those projects remain part of a longer-term redevelopment effort, not a finalized plan to transform the entire island immediately.
Mamdani also cannot change the 2027 closure deadline by himself. The City Council would have to approve legislation extending it to 2032.
For now, Rikers remains open, thousands of people remain in custody, and the city still has to build the jails intended to replace it.




